Online Dating—Too Many Strikes, a Few Fouls, and Hoping for a Home Run



**Disclaimer** When online dating and meeting a stranger in person, please use “uncommon sense”—meet in a public place, tell a friend where you’re going and when, and always have an exit strategy.  It’s better to be safe than to have to make them sorry for messing with you.

Dear Friends,


You were wondering when I would cover this.  That dating thing.  We expect spinsters to do it.  From the time she's a girl, a spinster’s family, friends, and colleagues start gently prodding her onto the dating field or gently justifying why she’s still single.  Here are a few “hints”:
  • From Grandma: I’m fifteen years old.  It's Christmas.  “Merry Christmas, honey.  I hope you like the little black purse I bought you.  It’s for dates.  Have you been on any lately?”  Sweet, but “no, Grandma.  I’m fifteen, and the only dating venue—the Dairy Queen—doesn’t open until March.” 
  • From a client:  I just became a lawyer.  I work for my father, the firm’s partner. The client says, “Thanks so much for helping me with that legal issue.  Oh, and did I tell you my first granddaughter was born?  I’m so excited!  So, when are you going to give your dad grandchildren?”  “Shhhh!!!” I respond.  “Keep your voice down.  You’ll give him ideas.”
  • From a guest at a wedding:  I had just given the maid of honor speech.  “Beautiful speech.  And you all look great in those bridesmaid dresses.  But don’t worry, your day to wear the white dress will come.  Speaking of, where’s your date?”  Behind the bar.  His name is Jack.  Jack Daniels.  Thanks for asking.
  • On a date with someone I met online: “You said you’ve been single for a long time.  Are you just hard to date?”  As I'm walking out, "Absolutely.  How did you know?  Goodbye."

I have many painful vignettes like these.  Although funny in hindsight, these adventures in spinsterhood are stressful.  There’s so much pressure to find “the right one” right away when every “one” I dated was not quite right for me.  So, I’d wander between dating and hiding.  My other dreams filled the time—college, work, travel, law school.  These things made me feel good.  Yet…., was I missing something?


In the spirit of adventure, I entered the online dating world last fall.  I had just become a lawyer, was making money, and could afford a few bad dates.  If nothing else, it would be entertaining, right?


More than I knew.  Now only five months later, I have had many first dates, some second dates, a few thirds, fourths, and fifths, and many awkward moments.  I was only reminded of how bizarre this mode of dating is when I, just a few weeks ago, went on my first non-online date in forever.  


Before I get to that, let's state the obvious: meeting people on the internet is weird.  You don’t know them.  They don’t know you.  You’re just swapping shiny profiles.  If you’re brave enough to meet after a few days or weeks of texting, that first date is a crap shoot.  Are they heavier or skinnier than their picture (i.e. catfishing)?  Are they too shy in person?  Do they never shut up?  Do they whine about failed dates?  Do they have shifty eyes and a missing wallet?  You hope not, but this person hasn’t been vetted by someone you trust, so you never know until it’s too late.  (More on that in a future post.)


A few weeks ago, I broke the online-dating cycle by going out with the cousin of a friend.  We had met once before, at my friend’s prompting, and that date went pretty well (no shifty eyes; he had his wallet).  He even had a nice enough time to ask me out again, this time to a Detroit Tigers’ game.  Thinking it would be fun, I accepted.  And it was!  We drank beer, I asked dumb questions about baseball (Me: “What is that big, ugly, yellow pole?  It’s blocking people’s view.”  Him: “Um, that marks the foul line.” Me: [God, I’m dumb.]), and we had a few laughs while watching the Tigers win.  We also met cool people sitting next to us.  We chatted about our jobs, that my date lives in Lansing, and that I live near Detroit.  All was going well until one of them leaned over and asked, “So, are you two on a Tinder date?”


TINDER???  Does this LOOK like a Tinder date?  Who takes a Tinder girl to a Tigers’ game?  No one works that hard for a hookup.  No one drives from Lansing to Detroit and back again in one day to get some action from a woman he met on Tinder.  Even if she were hot enough to be worth the drive, she’d probably ruin the game with her dumb questions (uhhhhh…..).  Why is that the assumption?  Is there no other way for people to meet than online?


Apparently not.  If you’re not online, you’re not in the game.  Too few people will date without the armor and convenience of the internet.  Too few people will risk introducing themselves to a stranger unless they can exit the conversation—turn off their phones—when it gets weird.  And I can’t blame them.  We’re so glued to our phones that any impromptu conversation seems an interruption.  Rather than risk meeting someone’s eye, we gaze at our screens and cling to whom we already know or can safely shut off.  Even though I fought online dating, hoping we would return to the open-faced friendliness of pre-cell-phone days, we haven’t and likely won’t.  


Whether dating online or in person, my story has been the same.  I have swung and missed.  A few times, I hit the ball and started running but only fouled out.  My eye is getting better at picking the right pitches, but I still don’t understand what that guy on the mound is doing.  At twenty-eight years old, my arms are tired, and I’m dusty and dehydrated.  I’ve been at this game since fifteen.  Friend after friend slides into home with a smile and a cheer while I swing through endless innings. 

Yet I play anyway.  There’s no crying in baseball!  Since I started dating again, I've gone interesting places, learned new things, and collected excellent stories Even if none of those men were the “one”, they took a risk in meeting me, and I respect that.  We may strike out, but so what?  The pitcher won’t outwit us forever, and there’s joy in playing the game.  Whether through a friend, on a Tinder date, or in line at the Dairy Queen, I'll take the chance of meeting the right person for me.  I've learned that life doesn't happen in the dugout; it happens on the field.  And I'm tired of sitting out.  Play as you like, but I'm aiming for the fence and that slow, triumphant stroll all the way home.   

Best wishes, and Go Tigers!


Super Spinster


P.S. Please comment below with the interesting things people have said to you about being single.  And don’t forget to share your dating stories—online and otherwise!

What is the best way to escape from a bad date?

Fun with Spinsters! Watches The Bachelorette

Dear friends,   Do “bachelorettes” have more fun?   Not if you’re a Fun with Spinsters! spinster, but “bachelorette” has become...